Fans loved Smith and his incredible Bonus Round puzzle solve, with one X user writing, “Geoffrey is the best #wheeloffortune player of all time. Holy smokes.” Another agreed, saying, “#Geoffrey on tonight’s @WheelofFortune may be my favorite contestant ever!

Fans of the game show took to the subreddit on Reddit to share their excitement. "The Jamaican guy on here tonight is a legend," wrote one fan, while another noted he was an "excellent puzzle solver." Fans also shared their enthusiasm on X (formerly Twitter ).