- Showing 1 - 36 out of 105 results for "2009 no mint mark formative years penny with a extra thumb"Sort by:FeaturedProduct added to your wishlist! View wishlistSign in to see your saved products on any deviceProduct removed from your wishlist! View wishlistSign in to see your saved products on any deviceSomething went wrong. Please try again later.Product is added to compare already. Please refresh the page.Product is not found in compare. Please refresh the page.5 Products already added. Please delete existing selection to add this.